When can you play as her?
Chapter 1 puts you in Lucia’s shoes for specific story sequences. Early in Chapter 2, you can explore as Lucia on your own. For a while the story still chooses who you control. Completing Coffee Break lets you make that choice in free roam.
Stuck before Lucia leaves prison? Find the release mission ↗Swap characters or meet up
While playing as Jason, keep the right direction held as you tap the shoulder button. You’ll take control of Lucia. When you’re playing as Lucia, use the same combination to switch back. If you want your partner to join you while you keep control, hold Right and choose the meet-up prompt with Triangle on PS5 or Y on Xbox.
If the other portrait is gray
Check whether the current mission calls for a particular lead. The map icon shows who can take it. Try the switch again once you’re back in free roam. If you’re already at home, step outside and check the partner menu again.